The meteorites are the main threat in this story and its
because of these that the cliffhanger worked as well as it did. On CD it didn’t
quite work but when we see it then despite the fact that the meteorites look
like big balls on string, it works due to the performances from Frazer Hines
and Wendy Padbury. After the initial reprise we are reminded about Gemma’s
death and its just as sad as in the previous episode.
Jarvis has lost a lot of hysteria from the previous episodes
and his death is a surprise but rather well done. After Gemma, he has been one
of the more entertaining characters from this story so it seems a shame that
they have killed both of these characters off.
Jamie and Zoe seemed to have buried the hatchet and Zoe has
taken on board what was said to her in the previous episodes. It seems like her
development has reached its conclusion. They work quite well together and its
good to see as they are about to spend an entire season together. I think the
way that Zoe gets into the TARDIS is quite interesting as she becomes a stowaway.
No reason is given why Zoe cant join them. It must be said she’s the worst
stowaway in history as she’s easily spotted by the Doctor. The Doctor tries to
scare her by showing her a clip from ‘Evil of the Daleks’ (episode two I
think!). This was used at the time because they were repeating ‘Evil of the
Daleks’ on BBC1 the week after this aired. However watching it now knowing that
tomorrow will be the start of season 6, this does seem somewhat of a out of
sorts thing to do.
I have finally found something good to say about Patrick
Troughton’s performance. The Doctor is quite active in this episode and his
best moment comes when he comes up with a way that kills a Cyberman. He’s still
hampered by a lack of action but at least he gets to do something Doctor-like.
The Cybermen ‘s convoluted plan continues and whereas it
seems to have taken second place to the meteorite plot, this seems to have been
switched around. For the life of me I don’t quite know why they don’t just
storm in and take the wheel. It’s not like they’ve got a massive arsenal to
fight against. They are also defeated too easily in my mind and this is why I
think that this has been a poor use of the creatures. Given that they have free
reign over the show now that the Daleks are gone, it seems a wasted opportunity
in my mind.
I like how they deal with the video calls. Especially
Troughton’s call when he speaks to Jamie, Zoe and the others and the direction
he looks in matches the positions of Jamie and Zoe. This is the first time that
I have appreciated Tristan DeVere Cole’s direction. The shot of the Cybermen
walking towards the wheel is another great moment and credit should go to him.I think that this was a good ending to an otherwise poor story. I think that they could easily have taken the Cybermen out of this story and it wouldn’t have made a bit of difference. Before watching this story a day at a time, I would have rated this story quite highly but watching it like I have done this time I cant help but fee disappointed. I think that the six episode format has worked (just) in this story and its only the Cybermen that have let the side down. I think that they have done wonders on Zoe’s character over the course of the story. Now we are about to enter the final season for Patrick Troughton as the Doctor, the final season in the 1960’s and also the final season in monochrome. I cant wait.
This fifth season has been largely quite good. I think that
started off really well with ‘The Tomb of the Cybermen’ before stumbling with ‘The
Abominable Snowmen’, then picking up against on a three story good run with ‘The
Ice Warriors’, ‘The Enemy of the World’ and ‘The Web of Fear’ before stumbling
against with ‘Fury from the Deep’. Whilst I cant say that this story is the
worst, its not the best. In fact out of seven stories, it ranks in fourth
place. Pretty much says that this story ends the season on a relatively good
note.
No comments:
Post a Comment