(654) Time and the Rani - Part 1

Ok so I enter the final stage of the original run of Doctor Who. This has come really fast because at the beginning of the year I was halfway through the Peter Davison era. It’s weird to think how much the show has changed in that short amount of time. During the 1970’s we only had one regeneration and during the 80’s we have now had three. So with Colin Baker having being sacked by JNT Michael Grade, the search was on for a new Doctor and JNT chose Sylvester McCoy. Unfortunately McCoy’s time doesn’t get off to the best of starts because Colin Baker refused to film a regeneration scene which is fair enough but it means that the ‘regeneration’ scene is one of the worst.

The way that Andrew Morgan managed to avoid showing us Colin Baker’s face is well done right up until the point where we see Sylvester McCoy in a blond wig. I suppose some credit should go towards production team for at least giving it a go. When McCoy has his first speech it starts off ok but I think the buffoonery to be rather ill-judged. Bonnie Langford is also badly served in this episode as she basically spends the entire episode either tied up or running everywhere.

We get new a new title sequence in this episode which is really good and is a breath of fresh air after six years of the same star filled one. One of the many problems with this serial is the preposterous idea that the Rani decides to pretend to be Mel to try and fool the Doctor. The purpose of this is that the Rani needs the Doctor’s help but thing is that it requires Kate O’Mara to dress, talk and act like Bonnie Langford which is a huge stretch of believability. The only good moment came when the Rani tries to convince the Doctor that Mel is dressed the same as her.

There are things that worked quite well in this episode. The bubble that is created whenever people trip an explosion is rather well done and one of the few effects that work well in this episode. Another good thing are the Tetraps which look good as a design and also serve a purpose in serving the Rani. The idea that Rani needs the Doctors help is something that works on a narrative level but I  don’t think that this was given enough screen time which is a shame.

The traditional trying of new costumes for the Doctor is something that seems to be as humorous as when Tom Baker costume change in Robot. We saw the costumes from Tom Baker, Jon Pertwee, Peter Davison and Patrick Troughton’s coat before we get the costume that McCoy wears. I think that it’s a much better outfit than the one Colin Baker wore and the only thing I would change is the question mark jumper. His performance is perfectly fine given that the material he is given isn’t the strongest. It’s never a wise thing to judge a new Doctor on their first story because it is usually the weakest of their stories.

There are very few positives to take from this episode and I have rated this episode 6.90 which is the first time that I have rated an episode in the sixes since episode three of The Horns of Nimon. I should say that I don’t think that the flaws with this story have anything to do with Pip and Jane Baker or Sylvester McCoy and Bonnie Langford. I think that circumstances behind the scenes meant that this story had zero chance of being anything other than poor. I do hope that the next three episodes will improve because things cant get any worse.

I am going to end on a stat by saying that this is the 129^th episode to be produced by John Nathan Turner and now overtakes Barry Letts as the longest serving producer in Doctor Who history.