Today’s episode is the final episode of 1978. It’s been
quite a year as far as the show has been concerned with some quite intriguing
stories (such as Underworld). One companion has left and another replace her. I
think that in terms of quality the show hasn’t really changed that much in a
year. This is episode 497 and is close to celebrating it Quincentenary episode
(500th) and that means that I am over 60% of the way through the
marathon. I am still on course to finish this marathon on August 2, 2015.
The opening episode was a bit of a disappointment and I
commented that this story wasn’t going to be one of Robert Holmes’ best
stories. The cliffhanger had Romana do something that I don’t think she does
very often and that’s scream when something does seem to attack her. Sadly its
not the for mentioned Kroll but someone dressed in a clam costume. There’s a
nice mystery that’s set up during an early scene between the Doctor and Romana
when the Doctor questions who is paying Rohm-Dutt when the Swampies don’t have
money. Sadly this is dismissed quite quickly by Romana.
When the stories move to the refinery I just find myself
being slightly bored with what going on. I never thought I would find myself
saying that a scene with Philip Madoc being boring. Madoc, Leeson & Neil
McCarthy (previously in ‘The Mind of Evil’) spend the episode looking at some
screen trying to decide what to do.
I forgot that John Abineri appears in this story. I forgot
because he is caked under green makeup and plays one of the swampies. Like
Philip Madoc, Abineri has had some impressive previous performances in Doctor
Who. I think that his best performance was in the 1970 story ‘The Ambassadors
of Death’ when he played General Carrington. But its still a good performance
and I think that he does the best with the green make up.
We get to see the Kroll of this story and its quite a good
design and looks quite disgusting but it is certainly one of the largest
monsters ever seen in Doctor Who. The effect used to show it infront of the
swampies is perhaps a little basic but it could have looked a lot worse and it
must have been quite difficult to achieve on location. Even though I know that
Kroll turns out to be the fifth segment, its still quite good as how they get
round the fact that they don’t know what the segment is by having all this
drama about sacrificing and that’s quite a clever thing to do.
This is definelty a stronger episode than yesterday’s. The
story feels like its actually going somewhere and building up towards something
which wasn’t the case yesterday. I am still more won over with the location
filming and the swampies than anything else but my opinion of the story hasn’t changed
I think that this is the weakest of the Robert Holmes stories. That said I
think that there is something about this story and its certainly stronger than ‘The
Pirate Planet’ and also ‘The Ribos Operation’.
No comments:
Post a Comment